2024 African Meeting, Abidjan, Côte d'Ivoire : June, 2024
Causal Effects in Matching Mechanisms with Strategically Reported Preferences
Marinho Bertanha, Margaux Luflade, Ismael Mourifie
A growing number of central authorities use assignment mechanisms to allocate students to schools in a way
that reflects student preferences and school priorities. However, most real-world mechanisms incentivize students to
strategically misreport their preferences. In this paper, we provide an approach for identifying the causal effects of
school assignment on future outcomes that accounts for strategic misreporting. Misreporting may invalidate existing
point-identification approaches, and we derive sharp bounds for causal effects that are robust to strategic behavior.
Our approach applies to any mechanism as long as there exist placement scores and cutoffs that characterize that
mechanism’s allocation rule. We use data from a deferred acceptance mechanism that assigns students to more than
1,000 university–major combinations in Chile. Matching theory predicts that students’ behavior in Chile should
be strategic because they can list only up to eight options, and we find empirical evidence consistent with such
behavior. Our bounds are informative enough to reveal significant heterogeneity in graduation success with respect
to preferences and school assignment.
Preview
![Page 1](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p1.jpg)
![Page 2](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p2.jpg)
![Page 3](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p3.jpg)
![Page 4](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p4.jpg)
![Page 5](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p5.jpg)
![Page 6](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p6.jpg)
![Page 7](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p7.jpg)
![Page 8](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p8.jpg)
![Page 9](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p9.jpg)
![Page 10](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p10.jpg)
![Page 11](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p11.jpg)
![Page 12](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p12.jpg)
![Page 13](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p13.jpg)
![Page 14](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p14.jpg)
![Page 15](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p15.jpg)
![Page 16](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p16.jpg)
![Page 17](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p17.jpg)
![Page 18](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p18.jpg)
![Page 19](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p19.jpg)
![Page 20](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p20.jpg)
![Page 21](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p21.jpg)
![Page 22](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p22.jpg)
![Page 23](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p23.jpg)
![Page 24](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p24.jpg)
![Page 25](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p25.jpg)
![Page 26](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p26.jpg)
![Page 27](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p27.jpg)
![Page 28](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p28.jpg)
![Page 29](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p29.jpg)
![Page 30](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p30.jpg)
![Page 31](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p31.jpg)
![Page 32](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p32.jpg)
![Page 33](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p33.jpg)
![Page 34](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p34.jpg)
![Page 35](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p35.jpg)
![Page 36](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p36.jpg)
![Page 37](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p37.jpg)
![Page 38](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p38.jpg)
![Page 39](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p39.jpg)
![Page 40](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p40.jpg)
![Page 41](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p41.jpg)
![Page 42](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p42.jpg)
![Page 43](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p43.jpg)
![Page 44](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p44.jpg)
![Page 45](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p45.jpg)
![Page 46](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p46.jpg)
![Page 47](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p47.jpg)
![Page 48](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p48.jpg)
![Page 49](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p49.jpg)
![Page 50](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p50.jpg)
![Page 51](/event_papers/download/265/116/1/BLM_p51.jpg)